Bribery case tussle opens US-UK rift


The US Department of Justice acted as a conduit for a complaint against the UK's anti-fraud agency from a prime suspect both were investigating as part of a multibillion-pound corruption probe, the Financial Times has learnt.

The unusual move by US prosecutors in 2018 amplified tensions between British and American anti-fraud agencies and came as the DoJ was attempting to secure the co-operation of the suspect, Saman Ahsani.

Both the DoJ and the UK's Serious Fraud Office had been investigating Mr Ahsani as part of a scandal surrounding Unaoil, a Monaco-based consultancy that his family had founded at the centre of a global web of bribery in the energy sector.

The blockbuster case has resulted in high-profile convictions on both sides of the Atlantic, but has caused a rift between the two agencies and sparked internal investigations at the SFO, including into the conduct of the agency's director, Lisa Osofsky.

Mr Ahsani's complaint in July 2018 about Tom Martin, the SFO prosecutor managing the UK's Unaoil probe, was given to the DoJ, which passed it to the SFO along with its own complaint about the same lawyer, according to documents seen by the FT.

At the time, the DoJ was battling with the SFO over Mr Ahsani; the UK authorities wanted to put him on trial while the US wanted him to help unlock other investigations into companies allegedly paying bribes.

In meetings between the DoJ and lawyers for the British-Iranian Ahsani family that year, the parties had discussed their frustration with Mr Martin, according to a lawyer involved.

Mr Ahsani's complaint filed to the DoJ stated that "disclosure of these concerns" was only to be made to parties "agreed between Mr Ahsani's counsel and the US Department of Justice".

The Ahsani family had previously complained to a UK judge about the SFO's tactics in a judicial review in 2016.

Mr Martin had also attracted complaints from Australian authorities investigating Unaoil. Only one of the 34 allegations against him was ultimately upheld by the SFO, but he was suspended in July 2018 and later fired.

In 2019, Mr Martin, who denies any wrongdoing, sued the SFO over his dismissal and awaits an employment tribunal hearing. The investigator appointed by the SFO in 2018 to review the claims against Mr Martin said it was "noteworthy" that Mr Ahsani's complaint came via the DoJ "rather than directly to the SFO", according to internal documents seen by the FT.

A US lawyer with knowledge of the case characterised the DoJ's handling of the complaints as an attempt to ensure senior SFO leadership were aware of the full scope of the allegations about Mr Martin. "There was no conspiracy or side deal with the Ahsanis' lawyers," the person said.

An individual close to Mr Ahsani's legal team said his complaint had been sent via the DoJ because the Monaco resident had chosen to co-operate with US law enforcement by that time.

The DoJ and SFO declined to comment when asked about the complaints. Mr Ahsani was arrested in April 2018 in Rome following a UK extradition request, but was speaking to the DoJ at the same time about a potential plea deal, triggering a diplomatic bust-up first reported by the Guardian.

He ultimately travelled to the US in August to co-operate, according to two people familiar with the events. Mr Ahsani and his brother, Cyrus, both pleaded guilty to US bribery offences in March 2019. Their father, Ata, who was wanted by the SFO, was never charged.

Susan Hawley, executive director at campaign group Spotlight on Corruption, said it was "absolutely extraordinary and frankly outrageous" that the DoJ "would act in concert with those accused of extensive and egregious corruption" to lodge complaints against the SFO.


Related Businesses
    - - Customer

    Copyright © 2020 by CreditRiskMonitor.com (Ticker: CRMZ®). All rights reserved.  You are not permitted to use this report or the information contained herein for any purpose not expressly permitted by CreditRiskMonitor.com, Inc. Except as expressly permitted by CreditRiskMonitor.com, Inc., you are not permitted, in whole or in part, to copy, alter, correct, adapt, translate, enhance, lease, sell, sublicense, assign, distribute, publish, otherwise make available to any third party, or prepare derivative works or improvements of this report or any of the information contained therein. You are not permitted to reverse engineer, disassemble, decompile, decode, or adapt the software, algorithms or other processes used to prepare this report, or otherwise attempt to derive or gain access to the source code of same. You agree not to remove, alter, obscure, combine or otherwise change any disclaimers, trademarks, copyrights, other intellectual property rights, proprietary rights, or other symbols, notices, marks, or serial numbers on or relating to any copy of the report or on marketing or other materials that CreditRiskMonitor.com, Inc. may provide to you. You will not use this report in any manner or for any purpose that infringes, misappropriates, or otherwise violates any right of any party, or that violates any applicable law.  
    The FRISK® scores, agency ratings, credit limit recommendations and other scores, analysis and commentary are opinions of CreditRiskMonitor.com, Inc. and/or its suppliers, not statements of fact, and should be one of several factors in making credit decisions.  Any reliance you place on the information in this report is strictly at your own risk. Except as expressly provided by CreditRiskMonitor.com, Inc., no warranties or representations of any type, including without limitation of results to be obtained, merchantability or fitness for a particular purpose, are made concerning any part of CreditRiskMonitor.com, Inc.’s service, including without limitation the FRISK® scores.  The information published above has been obtained from sources CreditRiskMonitor considers to be reliable.  CreditRiskMonitor.com, Inc. and its third-party suppliers do not guarantee or validate the accuracy and completeness of the information provided in this report, the underlying information input to create the FRISK® scores, and specifically do not assume responsibility for not reporting any information omitted or withheld.  By using this website, you accept the Terms of Use Agreement
    Contact Us: 845.230.3000
    Fundamental financial data concerning public companies may be provided by Refinitiv (click for restrictions)
    Friday, August 14, 2020